Skip to main content

Featured post

If Harveywetdog did Wikipedia - 15 years as an equestrian videographer

In April 2020, and in the interest of legacy, I penned a Wikipedia entry recording the thoughts and notable achievements of myself as Harveywetdog. I admit I was ignorant of the rules concerning self promotion on Wikipedia at the time; consequently my entry was unfortunately, although arguably correctly, deleted and my account expunged from the system. As a result my original words and links were sadly lost but nevertheless here is an attempt at a rewrite. Perhaps when I'm gone someone will be able to enter it onto Wikipedia on my behalf, to serve as a fitting epitaph for the exciting times I spent on the Harveywetdog Project.  

Have your say - British Eventing Commission Launches Safety Consultation

It's Survey Monkey time again, as Dame Caroline Spelman's Safety Commission moves into the public consultation phase. Making a full response took me a couple of hours but I encourage all of you who love eventing to have your say.

Safer Eventing for Horses and Riders: Independent Commission Launches National Consultation

The future of safety in British eventing is under the spotlight following the launch of a major independent review into how the sport manages risk for both horses and riders.

The Independent Eventing Horse and Rider Safety Commission, chaired by Dame Caroline Spelman, has opened a nationwide consultation seeking views from everyone involved in the sport. Riders, owners, coaches, organisers, course designers, officials, volunteers, veterinary professionals and families affected by serious incidents are all being encouraged to contribute.

Have your say
AI generated image ©Harveywetdog


Why the Review Is Happening

The review comes at a difficult time for the sport. Since May 2024, four riders have lost their lives following cross-country falls at events in Britain, while a number of others have suffered life-changing injuries. Horses have also been seriously injured or lost during competition.

Although British Eventing has continued to develop and improve its safety measures over the years, there has not been an independent review of eventing safety since the Hartington Report in 2000. The Commission has therefore been tasked with taking a comprehensive look at whether everything reasonably practicable is being done to reduce avoidable risks.

Importantly, the Commission is not investigating individual accidents or seeking to allocate blame. Instead, it aims to examine the entire safety system and identify where improvements can be made.

A Thorough Examination of Safety

The Commission will review a wide range of issues, including:

  • Safety data and how incidents are analysed
  • Horse welfare and injury prevention
  • Course design and fence technology
  • Rules, qualifications and progression pathways
  • Training and accreditation of officials and coaches
  • Rider education and preparation
  • Medical and veterinary provision at events
  • Safety culture and reporting of concerns
  • Leadership and governance across the sport
  • The impact of cost pressures and climate change

The goal is to understand not only where risks exist, but how safety decisions are made and whether existing measures are delivering meaningful results.

What the Evidence Shows So Far

The consultation document highlights that eventing has made substantial progress in safety over the last two decades.

Data collected since 2001 shows that rates of serious rider injury and fatality have fallen significantly compared with the early years of the century. However, progress appears to have slowed in recent seasons.

One of the clearest findings remains that rotational falls continue to present the greatest danger. Although relatively uncommon, they are far more likely to result in severe injury or death than other types of falls.

Research has also identified several factors associated with increased risk, including higher competition levels, previous poor performance, and recent horse fall history. These findings raise important questions about qualification systems, progression through levels, and how performance data can be used to support safer decision-making.

The Debate Around Frangible Technology

Fence technology is expected to be one of the most closely watched aspects of the review.

Frangible and deformable fence systems, such as MIM clips and frangible pins, are designed to reduce the likelihood of rotational falls by allowing parts of a fence to collapse under specific impact forces.

While there is evidence suggesting these technologies may be beneficial, relatively few fences currently incorporate them and questions remain about cost, practicality, effectiveness and standardisation.

The Commission will examine whether barriers to wider adoption can be overcome and whether further innovation should be encouraged.

Bringing Horse Welfare to the Forefront

A notable feature of the consultation is its strong emphasis on horse welfare.

While much previous safety work has focused on rider injuries, emerging research suggests that many horse fatalities in eventing are not directly linked to cross-country falls. Issues such as musculoskeletal injury, fatigue, heat stress and sudden death are receiving growing attention.

The Commission wants to better understand how horses are monitored before, during and after competition, what welfare information is currently being collected, and whether more transparent reporting is needed.

Looking Beyond Accidents

One of the recurring themes throughout the consultation is the importance of culture.

The Commission is seeking views on whether people feel able to raise concerns, report near misses and challenge unsafe practices. It is also exploring how lessons from incidents are shared and whether there should be more formal mechanisms for escalating concerns when they are not addressed.

Alongside this, the review will consider how volunteers, officials and coaches are supported to make difficult decisions in the interests of safety.

New Challenges Facing the Sport

The Commission is also looking beyond the fence line.

Rising costs have reduced participation levels across the sport and may be affecting riders' access to coaching, organisers' ability to invest in infrastructure, and opportunities for competitors to gain experience safely.

Climate change is creating further pressures, with hotter summers, harder ground conditions and more extreme weather events making course preparation increasingly complex and expensive.

Understanding how these broader challenges influence safety will form an important part of the Commission's work.

Have Your Say

The consultation is open until 23 December 2026 and forms a key part of the Commission's evidence-gathering process.

Participants can complete an online questionnaire, submit written evidence, attend stakeholder discussions or, where appropriate, speak privately with the Commission.

Following analysis of the responses, research and expert evidence, the Commission is expected to publish its final report in spring 2027. British Eventing has committed to publishing its response and outlining any actions it intends to take.

For a sport built on the partnership between horse and rider, the review represents an opportunity to shape the future of safety, welfare and confidence in eventing for years to come.





Links:

The future for eventing

Lessons learned at Bicton

Ethical safety case

An open reporting culture - some way to go

Georgie Campbell - a terrible tragic accident

Are we learning from these events?



 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

©Harveywetdog/Author - David Robinson CEng FIET 
David spent approaching 50 years in Her Majesty's Electricity Supply Industry before retiring
He was part of the highly successful design team on the Sizewell B Nuclear Power Station Project before spending 25 years producing safety cases to keep our aging AGR fleet generating for the good of the nation
He is responsible for the Harveywetdog YouTube Channel which he maintains as an outlet for his creative talents
David has twice experienced blood cancer treatment but absolutely refuses to be a victim
All views are of course his own but might be influenced by the medication he's had to take
 



Comments